The Tribune – Operation Bluestar Anniversary; Punjab: Re-emergence of radicals raises questions

Naveen S Garewal, Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, June 5. June 6, 1984, the day the Army launched an attack (Operation Bluestar) on the Golden Temple. It has been 28 years. Why then has the SAD-led Government, into its third term, allowed a ‘Blue Star Memorial’ in the Golden Temple Complex to come up? The BJP, a SAD alliance partner, is strongly opposed to building such a memorial, but has kept quiet because of civic elections in the state.

Deputy Chief Minister Sukhbir Singh Badal, who also holds the Home Portfolio, finds nothing wrong with the memorial. He says: “Hundreds of innocent devotees who were trapped in the Golden Temple lost their lives during the army attack in 1984. What is wrong if a memorial is built for them?” Apparently there is nothing wrong, except that it is the Damdami Taksal that is building the memorial with the support of the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandak Committee (SGPC) and SAD.

Memories resurface

It was the Damdami Taksal head, Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwala, who had moved into the Golden Temple complex along with his followers, fortified the Akal Thakt and took on the Army when it moved into the complex to liberate the holiest Sikh shrine. Though, the Army attack caused a deep emotional wound, it is only recently the SAD, which remained mum, has allowed the memories to be resurrected.

Developments, such as the SAD forming an alliance with the Sant Samaj, a predominantly religious body, and appeasing the Damdami Taksal during the post-poll phase can certainly be an attempt by the Akali leadership to neutralise the hardliners in Sikh politics by providing them an honourable return to the mainstream politics.

The re-emergence of fringe elements on the centre-stage of Sikh politics has led to several realignments and questions in Punjab politics. Started before the assembly elections to consolidate the Sikh vote bank by the SAD, the integration of radicals into the political mainstream has caused concern.

Panthic agenda

The inauguration of a series of historical monuments on the eve of Punjab elections was initially seen as a revival of the ‘Panthic Agenda’ (read appeasing the Sikhs) to draw political mileage. Though, denied by the Akalis, the timing and grandeur associated with the Sikh memorials did not leave much to imagination. But today, those watching Punjab politics want to know if the SAD was providing the radicals an honourable way to return to the political mainstream or are the radicals pushing their way back by bullying the Akalis.

Of late several important leaders of the Akal Dal Mann also known as SAD (Amritsar) that professes the cause of Khalistan have joined the Akali ranks. Organisations such as the Dal Khalsa have also returned to the mainline politics. But as of now, it is not clear if hardliners are being wooed back or the hardliners have the mainstream Akalis under some pressure.

While a memorial can be viewed as a move to please certain sections of society, but the decision to bestow the title of ‘Living Martyr’ on Balwant Singh Rajoana, the assassin of former Chief Minister Beant Singh, defies logic of the moderate Akali section. It is difficult to understand what interest can be served by eulogising a person held guilty of cold blooded murder and conspiracy.

SAD anomaly?

The Akal Takht is the highest temporal seat of Sikhs and is directly under the SGPC. It is the SGPC that appoints the Akal Takht Jathedar. At the same time, the SGPC is controlled by the SAD. Therefore, to say the SGPC does not have the SAD approval in honouring Rajoana would be misreading Punjab politics. The move at this juncture can only be seen as an attempt by the SAD to consolidate Sikh politics, now that there is no major threat to it in Punjab from the Congress.

The first major test for the SAD-BJP alliance would be the post-civic election reaction of the BJP to the “policy of appeasement” being adopted by the Akalis towards those who had once challenged the state. Will the Akali leadership be able to handle the situation they are trying to create in Punjab? Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal with all his experience will find a solution once he sees things getting out of control. There are not many in the ruling alliance who can boast of a similar expertise.

Amarinder doesn’t favour memorial

Chandigarh, June 5. President of the PPCC Amarinder Singh today said it was completely wrong to set up Operation Bluestar Memorial as it was not going to help the state in any way. He also condemned the attempts to glorify Balwant Singh Rajoana, convicted of murdering former Chief Minister Beant Singh. (TNS)

http://www.tribuneindia.com/2012/20120606/main7.htm

The Tribune – Tribune Analysis; SAD forced back to Panthic agenda

Naveen S Garewal, Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, March 26. In less than a week after the debate over the capital punishment to former CM Beant Singh’s assassin started, the focus of Punjab politics has shifted from development to Panthic agenda.

Convicted way back in 2007, Balwant Singh Rajoana was almost forgotten until March 10 when a local CBI Special Court issued warrant for hanging him till death. This too did not have much impact, except his sister Kamaldeep Kaur holding a press conference to highlight the issue. In the meantime, Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal along with his Cabinet was sworn in on March 12.

Again for a week till March 19, the issue was buried under the euphoria of the formation of a new government. After the warrants were issue for a second time on March 19, it changed everything for the state.

The Akal Takht, the highest spiritual and temporal body of the Sikhs, moved into action. Jathedar Giani Gurbachan Singh went to meet Rajoana in Patiala jail two days after the second warrant was issued, hoping to persuade him for a clemency petition.

The timing of the warrants has raised several questions. But what has transpired this week is even more intriguing. The theory doing the rounds in political circles is that Badal’s detractors tried their hand at fermenting trouble for the newly formed SAD-BJP government.

The move would have served two purposes: hamper development (the mantra of SAD success in the polls) and strain the relations between the SAD and BJP as both the parties have divergent stands on the issue.

However, two parties emerged stronger in the episode: the Beant Singh family, which was on the radar of the hardliners, managed to placate the radicals by saying they had no issues with clemency and Badal once again managed to show his political acumen by neutralising his detractors and putting the Congress on the defensive, forcing PCC chief Captain Amarinder Singh to issue a statement supporting clemency.

It is apparent that till the second warrant was issued on March 19, the government could not visualise its implications or was working on a plan. The Akal Takht Jathedar called a meeting to discuss the issue on March 23. The Jathedar, apparently under pressure from radical elements, declared Dilawar Singh, the “human bomb” who killed Beant Singh, as a ‘martyr’ and Rajoana a ‘living martyr’. He even issued an edict to the SGPC, the CM and the SAD president to seek clemency for Rajoana.

It is at this point that the SAD think-tank launched its counteroffensive. The SAD core committee directed the SGPC to petition for clemency to the President, something that forced the Congress also to issue a statement supporting the clemency move.

But, before the SAD core committee could ask the CM to make a statement on the floor of the Punjab Vidhan Sabha today, Badal had taken BJP leaders like LK Advani and Arun Jaitley into confidence. Therefore, there was not much uproar in House today when the CM expressed his inability in executing Rajoana.

Though the SAD has managed to neutralise the hardliners, one thing is clear that the Panthic agenda is still a sensitive issue in Punjab, which can be easily exploited.

http://www.tribuneindia.com/2012/20120327/punjab.htm#3

The Tribune – In poll mode, SAD revives ‘Panthic’ agenda

Naveen S Garewal, Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, November 28. After an experiment in social engineering, the Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) seems to have changed its strategy and has now decided to take a calculated risk by re-adopting the “Panthic agenda”.

At the same time, it has decided to keep distance from radical elements within the Sikh community. The spree of inaugurations of Sikh historical monuments at the fag end of the SAD-BJP government term clearly aims at garnering Sikh votes.

The brain behind the move seems to be that of SAD patron and Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal. Being a veteran politician, Badal Senior, it seems, has sensed the gradual erosion of the Sikh vote bank of his traditionally “Panthic” party over the years.

The alliance of the SAD with the BJP has further diluted this vote bank. Further, the underlying tension between the SAD and the BJP has made it necessary for the Akalis to consolidate their own position without banking on the BJP.

In turning the Khalsa Heritage Centre at Anandpur Sahib into a reality, along with dedicating three other monuments (in memory of Banda Bhadur at Chappar Chiri and the two Sikh massacres — small and big ghallugharas at Kanuwan and Kuper Heedha), Badal has a twin agenda. The prime aim is to garner support for his party from every possible quarter so as to retain power, with or without the BJP. Secondly, Badal wants to establish himself in the revered league of Akali leaders as Master Tara Singh and Sant Fateh Singh.

The move to confer the titles of ‘Panth Ratan Fakr-e-Qaum’ upon Chief Minister Badal by Akal Takht Jathedar Giani Gurbachan Singh aims at catapulting the Badal Senior into the galaxy of famous Akali leaders. As the Akal Takht Jathedar is appointed by the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandak Committee (SGPC) where the SAD has 157 out of 170 elected members, the move is being viewed nothing more than an act of sycophancy.

At the beginning of the current term of the SAD-BJP government, Badal was conferred upon with the title of “Sant-Siaasatdaan” (Saint-Politician). Gurcharan Singh Tohra, an astute politician and many-time president of the SGPC, was posthumously given the title of “Panth Rattan.” He was never a part of the government.

During the 2002-2007 Congress regime, Captain Amarinder Singh had managed to woo a large number of rural voters by streamlining procurement and series of other administrative measures. Since, the Congress does not want to lose its vote bank, built in rural areas, it has hit out at the SAD’s re-calibrated pre-poll strategy of reviving the “Panthic agenda”.

As a counter reaction, the SAD has raked up issues like “Operation Bluestar.” The inauguration of the Sikh historical memorials has also brought forth the increasing divide between the SAD and the BJP. During LK Advani’s Jan Chetna Yatra, the SAD made it a point to distance itself from the BJP leader for his controversial comments on Operation Bluestar in his book, ‘My Country My Life.’ Though BJP president Nitin Gadkari was present for the opening of the Khalsa Heritage Complex, the Punjab BJP president was “missing”.

The Akali strategy

- To check gradual erosion of the Sikh vote bank: The spree of inaugurations of Sikh historical monuments, at the fag end of the SAD-BJP government, clearly aims at garnering Sikh votes

- To reduce dependence on the BJP, its alliance partner: The underlying tension between the alliance partners has made it necessary for the Akalis to consolidate their position without banking on the BJP

- To keep distance from radical elements within the community and gain support from every possible quarter to retain power

http://www.tribuneindia.com/2011/20111129/main9.htm

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 193 other followers